I have read lots of differing statements about "All I have to do is kill her" I though it was a variation of the song "Three" As performed at L'Olympia, Paris. June 7th, 1982. Some people say it is a variation of "FOREVER" and some say Forever is a variation of "ALL MINE" or vice versa. Is there anyone who knows for sure.?!
I once had a copy of "All I have to do is kill her" on a white vinyl album (ok copy). But I really need to get a better copy on CD. where can I get it.
I think the basic structure is the same since the band played 'Three' during 1980 tour and 'Forever' or 'Three' or 'what the hell we want to call it' during 81/82/83/84 concerts (and sometimes later...) the title 'All I have to do is kill her' is only on some boot (i.e. 'M' from Paris 82 gig) so I think basically is the same...anyway some musician told me that the chord structure on 1982 version of 'Forever' was different than the 81 version so maybe you can consider 'All I have...' another song...
And so what????
Anyway, there are a lot of boot with that wonderful Paris 7-6-82 version so I think it's quiet easy to find it...
I really want to find the Paris, June 7 1982 performance because it was the day i was born!! Anyone know if it's available?? Hoping hoping...
All I have To Do Is Kill Her, to my understanding, evolved from All Mine, which was the Pornography Tour's answer to Forever; they are different songs, but serve similar purposes.
I think there is a soundboard copy of the Paris 82 show in the downloads section, but if not, I've got a copy and can try to figure out how to put something on Megaupload and upload All I Have To Do Is Kill Her sometime soon.
Quote from: tigermilk on May 04, 2008, 15:41:56
I really want to find the Paris, June 7 1982 performance because it was the day i was born!! Anyone know if it's available?? Hoping hoping...
Hi again tigermilk! D'you mean this show?:
http://visual.givemeit.de/alolympiaparis761982/
...Cause I've got it! I'll upload it tomorrow if Bloodflower hasn't beat me to it. Or, maybe a trade? 8)
Oh, and here's All I Have To Do Is Kill Her:
[link removed by the staff]
Good enough quality?
Yes that's the one! Looks like a great show! Do you have it all on CD?
Is downloading difficult?? Do I need to add any applications or sign up?
I'm so confused when it comes to these things... :oops:
Thanks for your help you two! :smth023
Cure fans are so nice
Quote from: Poe on May 05, 2008, 23:37:11
Oh, and here's All I Have To Do Is Kill Her:
[link removed by the staff]
Good enough quality?
dear poe, i'm sorry but please respect the forum rules:
no mp3s/mp3 sourced files whatsoever in this forum. :!:
http://curefans.com/index.php/topic,4197.0.html
also please check out the full audio policy, for details:
http://curefans.com/index.php/topic,4917.0.html
we want to promote quality file sharing, and thus only FLAC or other lossless formats around here.
thanks.
here's a good quality lossless version, comes from an old pptt MX+AUD(+FM) project:
Quote
Lineage: CD-R trade (from Vince D.) -> EAC (WAV) -> CD Wave (FLAC 5)
Quality: (SBD + AUD) SBD - A quality, Aud - B+ quality
Speed change : audacity
[...]
Notes:
Complete version of this famous live show.
Compiled and remastered by Vince D.
Lostflower4 used his magic ear to correct the speed.
Wabis kindly hosted several samples.
Karelgott speeded the soundboard tracks at x1.52128.
all mine (SBD + FM last 30 sec) 12:33 -- > http://www.megaupload.com/?d=6943FNBR
please don't reupload in mp3s.
thanks.
Quote from: japanesebaby on May 06, 2008, 06:57:16
dear poe, i'm sorry but please respect the forum rules: no mp3s/mp3 sourced files whatsoever in this forum. :!:
Damn. (http://www.cureconnections.com/images/smilies/eusa_doh.gif) Anyhow, it's a great show. Pornography sounds very, very evil...
Quote from: Bloodflower on May 04, 2008, 19:34:47
All I have To Do Is Kill Her, to my understanding, evolved from All Mine, which was the Pornography Tour's answer to Forever; they are different songs, but serve similar purposes.
I think there is a soundboard copy of the Paris 82 show in the downloads section, but if not, I've got a copy and can try to figure out how to put something on Megaupload and upload All I Have To Do Is Kill Her sometime soon.
All I have to do is kill her is definately the name from the first bootleg that showed up from this concert. On the deluxe version of Pornography the song is called All Mine.
Quote from: abcandreas on May 07, 2008, 09:22:11
All I have to do is kill her is definately the name from the first bootleg that showed up from this concert. On the deluxe version of Pornography the song is called All Mine.
Quote from: delma on August 20, 2006, 16:28:15
I think the basic structure is the same since the band played 'Three' during 1980 tour and 'Forever' or 'Three' or 'what the hell we want to call it' during 81/82/83/84 concerts (and sometimes later...) the title 'All I have to do is kill her' is only on some boot (i.e. 'M' from Paris 82 gig)
one thing is for sure: never trust a bootleg cover for any info. after all you don't know who wrote it - could have been some guy wdidn't know a thing about the band but was only looking into making some easy money by selling their music illegally. they were not fan-made covers so who cared what they wrote there? thus things are often named to just about whatever on bootleg covers. those old cs/lp/silver cd covers often even have dates and locations wrong many times etc. examples are easy to find.
here's some reading about 'forever'/'all mine':
http://www.impressionofsounds.com/stories/01.html
like stated there, i also think the main difference is the difference in the bass lines of 'forever' and 'all mine'. all else could just be called variations of either of those main ideas.
"all I have to do is kill her" is only referring to a sentence from the lyrics during "Forever" in Paris; but Robert also sang this sentence several times during other concerts from the "pornography tour" especially at the end of the tour. In any case this is a real name of a song.
Actually all live improvisations that share the same chord structure as All mine/All I have to... are unnamed (and should me named "Untitled" therefore), as "All mine" (London) and "All I have to.." (Paris) are only refering to the specific versions and are named after lines in their lyrics.
All live improvisations that are based on the structure of "Three" can be labelled as "Forever", that's why the band called the version on Curiosity "Forever (version)".
Got it? ;)
Quote from: Lostflowerboy on July 19, 2008, 08:55:32
Actually all live improvisations that share the same chord structure as All mine/All I have to... are unnamed (and should me named "Untitled" therefore),
All you have to do is change that title, actually, as there is already a 1989 Cure song called 'Untitled'...
Quote from: revolt on July 21, 2008, 12:22:52
Quote from: Lostflowerboy on July 19, 2008, 08:55:32
Actually all live improvisations that share the same chord structure as All mine/All I have to... are unnamed (and should me named "Untitled" therefore),
All you have to do is change that title, actually, as there is already a 1989 Cure song called 'Untitled'...
i think Lostflowerboy just means that trying to label all these versions under one title is misleading as long as the title is being derived from the lyrics - because the lyrics change all the time... (which makes you think why do people have to try deriving the name from the lyrics anyway? it's pretty clear that in this case it's futile and only causes these endless discussion of "what should we call this version or that version?". it makes us focus on what sort of name tags we should put to this or that song, whereas we could just as well forget the name and talk about the music/the individual performance of the "song" in question.... anyway.)
anyway, IF this "song" really has to get it's name from the lyrics, then "untitled" would be the only correct choice, i agree. and so the fact that there already is a well-known cure song by that name is just bad luck, in that respect...
but still, it would be a correct name, in a way.
*Shrugs* It's All Mine; doesn't really matter if that title is derived from one specific performance and shouldn't have been applied to all versions. That's how it is now; all versions are called All Mine, except for especially notable performances, namely All I Have To Do Is Kill Her. That Robert himself titles it All Mine just sort of ends anything resembling debate.