News:

Robert Smith: "The next album will be out hopefully in 2025"

Main Menu

Best of: The Head on The Door

Started by dsanchez, January 17, 2006, 16:08:55

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

Which is the best song in this album?

In Between Days
12 (10%)
Kyoto Song
8 (6.7%)
The Blood
8 (6.7%)
Six Different Ways
2 (1.7%)
Push
31 (25.8%)
The Baby Screams
2 (1.7%)
Close To Me
8 (6.7%)
A Night Like This
26 (21.7%)
Screw
1 (0.8%)
Sinking
22 (18.3%)

Total Members Voted: 98

KingOfSomeIsland

Inbetween Days, this and Plainsong were the songs that made me fall in love with the band


Trust...

PUSH

Powerful, great, I just love it  :-D
Vanilla smile and a gorgeous strawberry kiss x

turnpike74

Has to be Push. It took me seeing it live to aprreciate it, but its definetly powerful.


OnniHopeDream

Voted for Push! Easily best song on album, actually just one of my all time Cure favs ;p (Sinking would be 2nd tho)
And every day that I let slide Is one more day I never try To break the world To make my fate And with every day that I let go It's one day less I never know If it's always Always too late...

Lostflowerboy

Every song except "Screw" is one of my favourites. The perfect album?

mint car

I love each song on this album. I think that it is one of the greatest albums of 1985 year  ;)
[i]...sleep sweet child the moon will change your mind...[/i]

revolt

Quote from: Lostflowerboy on July 21, 2008, 16:35:49
Every song except "Screw" is one of my favourites. The perfect album?

If you don't like 'Screw' how can you say HotD is the PERFECT album?

Lostflowerboy

9 out of 10 is as close as it get's to perfection. "Screw" isn't bad either, it's just the one mediocre (but still interesting) song amongst 9 perfect ones, that's got to be there to make the others appear even more perfect.  ;)

Oh, time for a list again:

1. Head on the door
2. KMKMKM
3. Disintegration
4. Pornography
5. Seventeen Seconds
6. Bloodflowers
7. Faith
8. Wish
9. Three imaginary boys
10.The Top
11. Wild Mood Swings
12. The Cure

revolt

Quote from: Lostflowerboy on July 22, 2008, 12:38:12
9 out of 10 is as close as it get's to perfection. "Screw" isn't bad either, it's just the one mediocre (but still interesting) song amongst 9 perfect ones, that's got to be there to make the others appear even more perfect.  ;)

Oh, time for a list again:

1. Head on the door
2. KMKMKM
3. Disintegration
4. Pornography
5. Seventeen Seconds
6. Bloodflowers
7. Faith
8. Wish
9. Three imaginary boys
10.The Top
11. Wild Mood Swings
12. The Cure



Well, although THOTD is indeed very well conceived and has quite a few songs that I really like, I don“t think it represents well what The Cure are about. It's too poppy and too concerned with pleasing the crowds... There's no edge to it, it's actually the only Cure album in the 80's where The Cure take absolutely no risks!

Many songs have disposable lyrics and the ultra-polished production doesn't always work: a rock song like 'The Baby Screams' loses much of its power, for example.
Then "Push" is somehow recorded in a rawer way, but there's something about it that doesn't work for me (could it just be the lazy lyrics?)...

'Six Different Ways' is no masterpiece either, although it sounds fairly better here than it sounds live.

KingOfSomeIsland

They shouldve replaced Screw with A Few Hours After This... or A Man Inside My Mouth.

revolt

Quote from: KingOfSomeIsland on July 22, 2008, 18:18:54
They shouldve replaced Screw with A Few Hours After This... or A Man Inside My Mouth.

Well, I think that would hardly make it better... those are no great songs, either, at least for me. And even if AFHAT has a melody that kind of gets stuck in your head, the whole thing is produced in a way that would make it an out-of-place track in the album. It's almost only keyboards and voice, and the keyboards have a sound to them that could be described as 'cheap'...

Lostflowerboy

Yes, the final version of "A few hours..." sounds cheap, they really should've worked out the demo version that can be found on the Deluxe version (btw: the best bonus disc of all remasters beside Faith in my oppinion).

Whiskers

I don't understand the general dislike for the song Screw; it's one of my favorites on the album.

ExplicitMoment

I defied convention and voted for "Close To Me" - I just have fond memories of that song.

Although Push is a close second  :D

revolt

Quote from: ExplicitMoment on October 08, 2008, 21:39:15
I defied convention and voted for "Close To Me" - I just have fond memories of that song.


Hey, you're not alone on that one! I voted for "Close To Me" too. Just one of The Cure's best STUDIO pop songs ever.